The Secret of Shark Island vs There's a Demon Shark

[cartoonlover]

I've seen Shark Island quite a bit but I have yet to re-watch Demon Shark. To be fair Ill do it this way.

My Prediction: There's a Demon Shark in the Foggy Dark
What it will be: TBD

[matt]

Ah yes, the shark episodes. This should be fun

I’ll start out with There’s a Demon Shark in the Foggy Dark. If I am thinking about episodes that deserve more love, this one comes to mind. For starters, the plot is pretty unique. The crime, while unrealistic in it’s entirety, is a pretty cool idea. This one also has similarities to Scooby’s Night with a Frozen Fright in the setting and the idea of the monster being frozen in ice. In that comparison, Demon Shark actually wins against the Where are You episode. Overall, it’s an episode that deserves more love than it gets

Unfortunately, it is going up against a stone cold classic in Secret of Shark Island. If we are talking about best episodes of the New Scooby Doo Movies, this probably isn’t one of the first three but it is probably fourth for me. The hotel is awesome, and Sonny and Cher are probably among the best guest stars. The writers absolutely NAILED their dynamic. I was very entertained throughout the entirety of the episode. Honestly, one of the greatest Scooby episodes ever made and the easy winner for this comparison for me

[Doo]

I've got to pick "The Secret of Shark Island" just because of what a classic episode it is, Sonny and Cher's dynamic, and how creepy the hotel is. I really enjoy "There's a Demon Shark in the Foggy Dark" too, as like Matt said, the crime is super cool (despite being super unrealistic).